top of page

The End of Icing: Re-evaluating Injury Treatment Protocols for Athletes


In the annals of medical history, we find a curious study from 1946 by Dr. Massie titled "Refrigeration anaesthesia for amputation," published in the esteemed "Annals of Surgery." This study explored the use of ice as an anaesthetic during surgical procedures.



Little did they know that this chilling discovery would find its way into the realm of sports medicine years later.


Fast forward to 1978, when Dr. Gabe Mirkin introduced the world to the R.I.C.E approach in his best-selling book, "The Sports-medicine Book." Coaches and athletes everywhere embraced this mantra, believing it to be the ultimate solution for treating sports-related injuries. Rest, Ice, Compression, and Elevation - the four pillars of injury recovery. But as time marched on, the tides of sports medicine began to shift.



In March 2014, Dr. Mirkin himself made a bold statement, sending ripples through the athletic community. He said, "Coaches have used my 'RICE' guideline for decades, but now it appears that both Ice and complete Rest may delay healing, instead of helping."


This revelation sparked a revolution in the treatment of sports injuries. Scientists and medical experts began to question the long-held belief in the healing powers of ice. After all, the body's inflammatory response is a natural superhero, swooping in to save the day when injury strikes. When an injury occurs, such as a sprained ankle, our body's natural defence system springs into action. Inflammatory cells, like white blood cells, swiftly rush to the site of pain, initiating the healing process. Among these cells, tiny warriors, called neutrophils get to work, eliminating bacteria in case of an open wound. Meanwhile, macrophages come in, consuming damaged tissue cells caused by the initial trauma. Think of them as little vacuum cleaners, clearing the way for the next phase of healing: muscle repair and regeneration, powered by an anabolic hormone called Insulin-like Growth Factor (IGF-1) released by these cells.


In essence, inflammation is a fundamental biological response following an injury - an essential part of the healing process. It's not the villain it's often made out to be.

Swelling is necessary - and it contains the build up of waste following the injury. This needs to be removed via the lymphatic system - if this waste is allowed to accumulate - then it can become problematic to the body.


While chronic inflammation may contribute to certain diseases, like autoimmune disorders, acute inflammation plays a pivotal role in muscle regeneration after injury. It's a natural and beneficial process. Inflammation brings essential nutrients and immune cells to the scene, kickstarting the healing process like a well-orchestrated symphony. But, alas, icing could disrupt this beautiful harmony. Interestingly, inhibiting inflammation, which occurs when we use ice on an injury, can actually hinder the healing process.


Placing ice on an injured area acts as a roadblock for the white blood cells attempting to reach the injury site. It stunts the natural inflammation process that the body wants and needs to carry out. (Tiidus PM. Alternative treatments for muscle injury: massage, cryotherapy, and hyperbaric oxygen. Current reviews in musculoskeletal medicine. 2015;8(2):162-7.)



So, while icing may seem like a helpful approach, it can actually delay the healing process from ever getting started in the first place. Picture this: icing cools down the blood vessels, causing them to constrict, which in turn limits the crucial blood flow to the injured area. Less blood flow means fewer nutrients and immune cells rushing to aid in the recovery process. It's like putting up a "Do Not Disturb" sign when your body's natural healing mechanisms are ready to party!


In summary, studies have shown that alternative treatments like massage, cryotherapy, and hyperbaric oxygen can be more beneficial for muscle injury recovery compared to traditional icing methods. These approaches support the body's natural healing processes and promote better muscle regeneration.


Enter the new-age hero, the P.O.L.I.C.E approach - Protection, Optimal Loading, Ice, Compression, and Elevation. Hold on to your ice packs; occasionally they are ok. If you have a hot swollen visibly red joint or muscle - then yes, by all means - pop some ice on it. If it isnt hot and red - then why are you trying to cool it down??

In Chinese Medicine circles - we have a saying that 'ice is only good for preserving dead people.' - we use cold herbs on injuries - such as in the form of 'Hit Fall' medicine - also called 'Dit Da Jow' but they are combined with warm herbs to protect the body and maintain circulation....


Ice still has its role, providing short-term pain relief. But the focus has shifted to the importance of early movement and optimal loading of the injured area. Think of it like giving your injury some tender love and care while encouraging it to get back on its feet. Early movement and controlled exercises stimulate blood flow, promote tissue repair, and prevent those muscles from withering away like neglected houseplants.


So, the verdict is in - icing an injury is no longer the gold standard. While it may still offer some relief, the P.O.L.I.C.E approach has taken the spotlight, incorporating a more balanced approach to treatment. As we dive deeper into the world of sports medicine, let's embrace these revolutionary insights. Let's celebrate the marvels of our body's healing powers and strive to provide the best care for our beloved athletes. After all, it's not just about a quick fix; it's about ensuring their long-term health and peak performance. Here's to a new era of injury treatment - one that's grounded in science and fuelled by progress!


49 views0 comments

Comments


bottom of page